I struck straight into the heath; I held on to a hollow I saw deeply furrowing the brown moorside; I waded knee-deep in its dark growth; I turned with its turnings, and finding a moss-blackened granite crag in a hidden angle, I sat down under it. High banks of moor were about me; the crag protected my head: the sky was over that.

Jane Eyre Charlotte Brontë 1847


Most people, who know anything about the Brontë family, will know that they lived in a gloomy vicarage in Hawarth, West Yorkshire, on the edge of the rugged Pennine uplands. Most of us, too, will have seen the windswept ‘Cathy come home’ film clip renditions of scenes from Emily Brontë’s dark romance Wuthering Heights. And so, if we think of it all, we probably imagine that Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre is set in her home county too.

And we’d probably be wrong. Circumstances and too many clues suggest that it was Hathersage and its environs in Derbyshire’s Dark Peak that informed the landscape of Charlotte Brontë’s imagination as she wrote Jane Eyre.

If you read my last post on the Seven Stones Bronze Age circle on Hordron Edge you will have seen the above vista – Stanage Edge above Moscar Moor. The path to this part of the moor begins at Cutthroat Bridge on the Glossop – Sheffield road just south-west of the old boundary stone at Moscar Cross. From here the hills fall away to the Derwent Valley and the vast Ladybower Reservoir built in the 1930s. You can just see a glimpse of the reservoir in the next photo taken from Hordron Edge.  It would have been a steep river valley in Brontë’s time. At the reservoir the road divides – west for Glossop and Manchester, and south for Bamford and Hathersage.


This next quotation is one of the possible ‘real location’ clues. It describes Whitcross, the place that many now identify as Moscar Cross. This isolated spot is where Jane Eyre is dropped by the coachman because she hasn’t enough money to pay for the onward journey. So begins her desperate wandering and lonely night out on the moors. She has just run away from Thornfield Hall and her thwarted marriage plans. Husband to be, Edward Rochester, has been exposed. He is already married to a lunatic wife whom he keeps locked in the attic. Jane’s sense of shock, loss and emotional distress are heightened as she loses herself physically, choosing to walk away from all identifiable landmarks and into the wild unknown:

Whitcross is no town, nor even a hamlet; it is but a stone pillar set up where four roads meet: whitewashed, I suppose, to be more obvious at a distance and in darkness. Four arms spring from its summit: the nearest town to which these point is, according to the inscription, distant ten miles; the farthest, above twenty. From the well-known names of these towns I learn in what county I have lighted; a north-midland shire, dusk with moorland, ridged with mountain: this I see. There are great moors behind and on each hand of me; there are waves of mountains far beyond that deep valley at my feet.

And why, you might ask, are people so keen to think that Whitcross is Moscar Cross? Does it even matter?

Of course it doesn’t. That a writer was drawing on what they knew of actual places when creating their fictional settings doesn’t necessarily add to our enjoyment of the story. On the other hand, to know that they had a definite somewhere in their mind’s eye may offer a few insights into the nature of the creative process.

I’ve written elsewhere about the importance of PLACE in fiction, and that SETTING is more than just a location. In the best stories the evocation of place can be as crucial as the conjuring of believable characters to occupy it.

Writers need to do their world-building homework very carefully – the outcome of which is likely to be more successful if they are summoning places and situations that have already stirred their creative impulses. When they come to write, they are already firing on all senses: can walk in their character’s shoes; feel through their skin; see through their eyes.  And if the narrative warrants something more complex, there can be, by way of dramatic or comic irony, further interplay between what the reader may ‘know’ of the place and what the protagonists are seen to experience.

Of course all creative people make up things, but they also start their imagining from what they know: from people, places, things that have struck or affected them.

But to return to the Hathersage connections and Jane Eyre  and the real reason why I’m indulging in this piece of literary tourism. For those of you who have read my recent posts you’ll know that the small Peak District town of Hathersage has personal family connections. My ancestors farmed on its outskirts from at least the late 1600s to 1892 (see Stepping Stones Through Time and Ancestor Sleuthing in Derbyshire ).

My great great Fox uncles and aunts of Callow Farm were exact contemporaries of Charlotte Brontë, and some of them would have been around in 1845 when the writer spent three weeks in Hathersage, staying with her very close friend from school days, Ellen Nussey.

Ellen was the vicar’s sister, and he, Henry Nussey had just got married and was away visiting his mother with his new bride. At some stage Charlotte had apparently refused a marriage proposal from Henry (he who apparently liked to draw up lists of attributes for any potential wife) and so his absence was perhaps taken advantage of by Ellen. In any event, the two women spent this time going out and about and visiting local notables.

And while I don’t for a moment think that these outings included afternoon tea at Callow, I am quite enjoying the notion of them sharing the ‘same air’. In fact Callow may well have been a sad place in the summer of 1845. In March of that year, my 3 x Great Grandmother, Mary Ann Fox nee Williamson, had died of ‘general dropsy’ at the age of 57. She is a bit of mystery, possibly ‘a London lady’ who in circumstances unknown became engaged to local bruiser and fist-fighter, Robert Fox of Callow. They were wed by marriage bond in Southwell Minster in 1812. She was anyway survived by four daughters and three sons, and although some of the girls look to have been employed in households outside the area around this time, I’m thinking there may have been Fox family members at Hathersage church on those Sundays in July when Charlotte and Ellen doubtless attended.

One of the places the two women definitely did visit on several occasions was North Lees Hall, below Stanage Edge, near Hathersage. It was lived in at the time by members of the very populous Eyre dynasty whose antecedents had built it in the 1500s.

North Lees BBC2Photo credit: BBC

The Eyres had occupied many such houses in the area over the previous several hundred years. In fact my Fox family legend (totally unsubstantiated) has it that the first ancestral Derbyshire Fox was the steward of the vanquishing Eyre who came to England with William the Conqueror in 1066, and that this relationship continued down the ages – from which you may also surmise that some of my ancestors told rather good, if dodgy tales. In fact they were still telling this one when Great Great Grandfather George sold up at Callow in 1892. I know, because it was picked up at the time and featured by several local and regional newspapers.

Nor was Charlotte apparently averse to recycling tales. North Lees came with its own legend that told of one Agnes Ashurst, a mad woman who was confined to a room on the second floor. This room had padded walls to stop her injuring herself, but like Rochester’s wife, Bertha, she also died in a fire.

Definitely it was too good a yarn not to re-use and develop then. It also well illustrates another aspect of the on-going writerly process – the jackdaw syndrome of gathering in every shiny fragment and titillating curiosity just in case such treasured little nuggets may one day serve some plot.

Anyway, I will finish this present ramble with the Jane Eyre description of Thornfield Hall. Take a look again at the photo of North Lees. What do you think – a convincing source for Rochester’s domain of dark secrets and the scene of Bertha Rochester’s shocking demise?

I stepped over the threshold. It was a fine autumn morning; the early sun shone serenely on embrowned groves and still green fields; advancing on to the lawn, I looked up and surveyed the front of the mansion. It was three storeys high, of proportions not vast, though considerable: a gentleman’s manor-house, not a nobleman’s seat: battlements round the top gave it a picturesque look.

copyright 2016 Tish Farrell

35 thoughts on “JANE EYRE WAS HERE? Or was she?

  1. Your thoughts on how fact feeds fiction are very interesting. The Bronte landscapes are such an integral part of their stories. When my daughter lived in Ireland she lived high up on a mountain top in an old stone cottage. Walking with her across the uplands in the wind with the (crazy) husband ranting in the cottage below we both felt we were characters in a Bronte novel. In our case it was Wuthering Heights. Of course the Bronte novels aren’t set in Ireland but their stories and characters are so intricately linked to those wild, craggy landscapes of Britain and Ireland. They operate like archetypal tales that depict ways of being and feeling that the landscapes induce in many.
    Of course this is getting off the track of your post. It would be wonderful to be able to spend time roaming around landscapes that are so powerfully linked to the Bronte’s and to your own personal history. Perhaps you are experiencing the birth of a new creative impulse – an historical novel set in that landscape perhaps.

    1. Thank you for all those thoughtful insights, Suzanne. I am just a touch haunted by this Derbyshire landscape, but as I said to Bill at pinklightsabre, it’s also to do with reading Wide Sargasso Sea while I was there – by Jean Rhys. If you don’t know it, she wrote Bertha Rochester’s back history in Jamaica, and it’s stunning. Truly a work of its setting – so hot and tropical.

      1. I haven’t read The Wide Sargasso Sea though I have heard of it. I will look out for it. I often feel haunted by the uplands of Ireland too. There is a deep dark even primeval power to such landscapes. More that than, the Mother Goddess still seems to stride across the hilltops. From the mountain top where my daughter lived we could see The Paps – two breast like mountains sacred to the goddess since ancient times. My daughter climbed one and said there is a ring fort on the very top that resembles a nipple.

  2. Thanks for the literary tour Tish!
    What an enjoyable read – I sat back to slowly soak it up –
    And the relative who died of “dropsy” – how sad – but I bet she married the bruiser-dude because of real heart thunder love ❤️-
    So chewing on the rest – beautiful post!

  3. “The same air,” that’s good Tish — wink, wink. I am sorry to say Jane Eyre was wasted on me, and probably most folks my age, when I read it around 15 or so in my advanced English reading class. Or possibly later in college, I can’t remember, but I didn’t get it. The clips you include here have whet my appetite though. And I like how you stepped out of the piece to talk about the creative process, the creation of place and setting. I am doing that now with pieces I’m writing from about 20 years ago, and it’s fun drawing on sense memory vs. actual diary entries; somehow I think the setting created is richer in its imperfections, perhaps more fantastic with the patina effect of memory, and how much of that is drawn from the senses. Amen to that, and Charlotte B. — Bill

    1. Oh please do read Jane Eyre again. And then read Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys. I found the latter in Derbyshire after years of meaning to read it. She writes the missing part of the story, and its haunted me for the last 2 weeks. It’s only short. See – I’m setting you homework now! And I didn’t even notice that pun!! Keep up the great writing.

      1. Thanks for the tip and encouragement Tish — the best puns are like that, they just creep up on you.

  4. Oh, how you challenge my mental laziness, and prompt me to start thinking again. This post goes in so many directions, and yet it all hangs together beautifully. I really enjoy your imaginative projection of your family and Charlotte into the same church. And then there is your riff on family stories, the quotes from “Jane Eyre”, the reflections on the power of place in fiction (something detective stories are oddly good at.) I remember mapping “Treasure Island” when I was reading it to my mob, and being astonished at how all the bits of this imaginary island fitted together. Did Stevenson have a particular place in mind, I wonder? Or did he draw a map and work from it with details of a patchwork of places?

    An aside. I reread “Jane Eyre” recently after seeing a splendid dramatic version by the National Theatre in the picture theatre in Narooma on a sunny Australian day. There’s an incongruity of setting.

    1. Thank you for all that lovely feedback, Meg. As to RLS, I bet he had drawn a map, maybe several. He came from a family of lighthouse builders after all 🙂
      Also love your image of antipodean Jane.

  5. Great post Tish
    It was a fascinating read and I really must read Jane Eyre again.
    I also love linking fiction to real locations. I use it to enhance my travels – to give a feel of the past, of the place’s character.

  6. Fascinating. I love the way you weave the history of the land and the lives of your ancestors with the Bronte family. It is such a long time ago that I read Jane Eyre and all those other classics. Maybe it is time to reread some of them.

    1. I had a Bronte ‘read-in’ last winter when I had fluey bug. I was astonished how much I enjoyed the books; and actually how ‘modern’ much of the writing is.

      1. Not a Bronte, but have you read Emma by Alexander McCall Smith? A modern version of the Jane Austen book and I loved it – of course you have to take some of the characterisation with a pinch of salt or maybe Smith’s undeniable sense of humour, as he managed to make Emma appear quite unlikable. Now I must definitely seek out the original.

  7. Jane Eyre was read to my primary school class a couple of years too early – as were several other classics, and I hated it. I tried it again as a young adult and failed, so I’m sad to say it isn’t a book I’ve enjoyed. I do love the possibility of Ms Bronte taking tea at allow though!

  8. Yesterday was the 169th anniversary of the novel’s first publication. Makes me think about the wild places in Derbyshire and how little they have changed since 1847. For me, they provide a feeling of continuity amidst the stress-induced pace of change and along with the connection to our ancestors and novels like Jane Eyre, I like to see them as meeting places between the past and present and as anchorpoints at which to pause and reflect. You have expressed this beautifully, thank you, Tish.

  9. Tish, very interesting. I read this long ago, don’t think I actually loved it. But there’s some classical music I don’t actually love either.

  10. I love your thought about ‘sharing the same air’. I have a similar feelings I enjoy, but in the ‘other direction’ – I like thinking about who has stood in a certain place before me. Who has walked through these doors, looked out on this view… it makes everything feel more important 🙂

    1. Little John is indeed in Hathersage not far from my Fox lot. There’s a story about a marker stone up behind Callow Farm from where Robin Hood is supposed to have fired an arrow that flew 2 miles across the valley and landed in the spot in what is now St Michael’s churchyard, so marking the spot where Little John was to be buried. The stone is called Little John’s Flight or Robin Hood’s Stoop and is above the lane near Offerton Hall. A good ol’ yarn.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.